Members of the Scottish Secondary Teachers’ Association have decisively rejected the revised package of cuts in teachers’ salaries and conditions proposed by the employers’ organisation, COSLA. In an indicative ballot the members voted: –
93.6% to reject the offer
6.4% to accept
48.7% turnout
During a period of exam preparation and school holidays a 49% turnout in a second ballot is remarkable. Our thanks and congratulations to every member who voted.
At the meeting of the Teachers’ side of the SNCT held at 3pm today SSTA representatives formally dissented from the decision made to accept the Cosla proposal. Full wording of the statement made at the meeting can be read below.
The SSTA representatives request that their formal dissent to the Agreement be recorded. In particular, but without prejudice to their other objections, they further request that it be noted for the record that the arrangements proposed for supply teachers may be in breach of the Part Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000 and or of the Fixed-Term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002. In particular they do not accept such arrangements can justified on objective grounds in terms of Regulation 5 (2) (b)of the Part Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations or Regulation3 (3) (b) of the Fixed-Term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002. In these circumstances, the SSTA representatives also wish it to be recorded that the SSTA reserves the right to support their members in any future litigation which any member may bring in terms of the Part Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000 and or the Fixed-Term Employees (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2002.
Ann Ballinger
General Secretary
28 April 2011
At the meeting of the Teachers’ side of the SNCT held at 3pm today SSTA representatives formally dissented from the decision made to accept the Cosla proposals. The SSTA does not accept the proposals and reserves the right to legally challenge any detriment to the pay or conditions of members.
Further advice and information will be circulated to members during the next 10 days.
Yours sincerely
Ann Ballinger
General Secretary
Early results from the consultative ballot on the revised proposals from COSLA are a clear and emphatic rejection of the proposed detriment to the conditions of service of all teachers.
More than 90% of SSTA members voting have rejected the revised proposal, mirroring the results of the ballot on the previous proposal.
The Teachers’ side of the SNCT meets today, Thursday 28 April, when a formal decision will be made. You will be informed of this decision immediately after the meeting ends.
Further information will be sent to schools as soon as the situation becomes clear and certainly over the next two weeks.
We are grateful to all members who took the time to vote for a second time and all those who contacted the Association to offer support.
Colleagues
The consultative ballot on the revised proposals from COSLA will close one week from now. The seriousness with which our response is listened to depends as much on the number of votes cast as it does on the results. A return of 50 or 60% will be dismissed as indicating the agreement of 40 or 50% of members. Please take a few minutes to vote either by post or online. The future of our profession depends on our ability to fight to protect teachers’ hard-won conditions of service.
Dear Colleagues
I am grateful to members who have forwarded comments made by other unions concerning the purpose of this ballot. If anyone is confused I hope the following is helpful.
Consultative ballots are used by this Association to:
The overwhelming view of our members (being a democratic body) will guide OUR policy.
Changes in Conditions of Service may be imposed on you by your employers. If that happens we will fight it by whatever means are available to us. One thing is certain. If our membership accepts the current proposals this Association has no mandate for further action.
Best wishes
Ann Ballinger
General Secretary
Full details of the revised proposals can be viewed here.
Members wishing to register their vote online can do so using the link below. You require your ballot paper with the unique reference number to vote. You must enter the reference number when you vote.
Please note that if a vote is registered online and a postal vote is also made, BOTH votes will be regarded as spoilt papers.
The result of the consultative ballot will be published on our website as soon as possible after the ballot closes at 12 noon on 28 April 2011.
Salaries and Conditions of Service Committee met today, Monday 28 March 2011, and agreed unanimously to ballot members on the new COSLA proposals and recommend rejection. The committee believes this proposal constitutes an attack on some of the most vulnerable members of our profession, further reducing their earning capacity. Other elements of the proposal constitute an attack on specific members of our profession many of whom accepted earlier changes in good faith, believing the assurances of protection from employers.
A ballot paper will be sent to all members employed by a local authority this week. If your ballot paper does not arrive, or if you are have not informed us that you are employed by a local authority, please contact the office as soon as possible. Please take the time to vote in this ballot! Every vote counts and our voice will only be listened to if the results prove that the vast majority of members have responded.
Full details of the revised proposals can be viewed here.
Members wishing to register their vote online can do so using the link below. You require your ballot paper with the unique reference number to vote. You must enter the reference number when you vote.
Please note that if a vote is registered online and a postal vote is also made, BOTH votes will be regarded as spoilt papers.
The result of the consultative ballot will be published on our website as soon as possible after the ballot closes at 12 noon on 28 April 2011.
Proposed Changes to Pay and Conditions 2011
1. The three parties to the SNCT (the Scottish Government, COSLA and the Teachers Side) referred to below as the ‘three parties’ agree to abide by the conditions set out in Appendix 1 attached.
2. The three parties affirm their commitment to the independently chaired review of all aspects of the McCrone Agreement chaired by Professor McCormac.
3. The three parties agree that following the outcome of the review chaired by Professor McCormac they will have tri-partite discussions looking at issues relating to teacher employment with the intention that any agreed decisions will be in place by August 2012.
4. Member Councils shall undertake to protect the number of teacher posts as far as possible in order to secure:
– places for all probationers who require a place under the induction scheme in August 2011;
– sufficient teaching posts available for all probationers to apply for who achieve Standard for Full Registration in summer 2011 (i.e. successfully complete their probation); and
– a reduction in the total number of unemployed teachers.
5. The three parties agree to regard these objectives as having been met if the number of FTE teachers in publicly funded posts in Scotland reported in the census taken in September 2011 is at least 51,131
6. If the number of FTE teachers reported in the census falls below that number, then
– the SNCT will agree changes to the measures listed in Appendix 1 affecting teacher terms and conditions that reduces the total value of the package by an amount equivalent to £40,000 for each FTE teacher below 51,131, including the possibility of reversion to the status quo ante, OR
– Where the parties to the SNCT agree that, based on census returns from individual councils, failure to achieve the figure of 51,131 FTE teachers is due to the actions of a small number of councils, SNCT may recommend to Scottish Government that, as an alternative, any sanction is applied to these Councils in a proportionate manner, having regard to the changes proposed in Appendix 1 in negotiations in the SNCT, provided that it is absolutely clear that these Councils’ actions have materially contributed to the failure to comply. Where such a sanction is applied to individual councils, there would be no change to the national terms and conditions proposed in Appendix 1 of this agreement.
If either of these sanctions is applied, Scottish Government will not take any further action in response to failure to achieve the teacher employment objectives.
Appendix 1
This document sets out the terms of proposed changes to the pay and conditions of teachers and associated professionals. It consists of six specific elements, details of which are set out below. It also includes a proposal to increase the local government settlement.
1. Pay Agreement 2011-2013
There will be no pay award for teachers and associated professionals for the period from 1 April 2011 to 31 March 2013. The awarding of additional salary points for teaching service, as set out in the SNCT Handbook Part 2, Section 1, paragraphs 1.15 to 1.20, will not be affected by this agreement.
2. Conservation for Promoted Post Holders appointed before 1 April 2001
The conservation arrangements set out in the SNCT Handbook Part 2, Section 1, paragraph 1.63 shall be amended as follows:
From 1 April 2011, a promoted post holder currently in receipt of lifetime conservation shall receive a period of cash conservation (as defined in paragraph 1.62) until 31 March 2016 after which the conservation arrangements will cease to apply. This agreement applies to all promoted post holders for whom the previous terms of paragraph 1.63 applied.
From 1 April 2011 until 31 March 2013, a promoted post holder appointed to a post before 1 April 2001 and:
a) whose post is re-sized during that period and the salary is downgraded; or
b) who is transferred during that period, for reasons other than inefficiency or indiscipline, to another post, which has a lower salary;
shall receive a period of cash conservation (as defined in paragraph 1.62) until 31 March 2016 after which the conservation arrangements will cease to apply. This agreement applies to all promoted post holders for whom the previous terms of paragraph 1.63 applied.
From 1 April 2013, any promoted post holder appointed to a post before 1 April 2001 and;
a) whose post is re-sized from that date onwards and the salary is downgraded; or
b) who is transferred from that date onwards, for reasons other than inefficiency or indiscipline, to another post, which has a lower salary;
shall be entitled to a period of three years cash conservation.
In addition, the SNCT will provide advice to councils on mechanisms which may be utilised as means of minimising costs in relation to conservation. These will include the following:
i. permanent or temporary redeployment;
ii. where redeployment is not possible, direction from the employer that the employee carries out other duties that reflect, as far as is possible, the level of payment that they receive; and
iii. early retirement.
3. Annual Leave
From the leave year commencing 1 September 2011, the annual leave entitlement of teachers and music instructors, currently set out in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Section 5, paragraph 5.3, shall be 40 days per annum. The balance, up to the current entitlement, will be redefined as School Closure. In addition, the daily and hourly rates of pay, set out in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Section 1, paragraph 1.5 shall be amended and will be 1/235 and 1/1645 respectively. The rate of accrual of paid leave, as set out in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Section 5, paragraph 5.4 shall also be amended and will be 0.2051.
The working year of teachers and music instructors shall remain at 195 days.
From 1 September 2011, teachers and music instructors who return from maternity or adoption leave and who wish to take the balance of annual leave that has accrued during that leave, shall, in the first instance, be directed to take this leave during School Closure periods.
Further, employees who have accrued statutory leave during sickness absence shall, in the first instance, be directed to take any such leave which they have accrued and not taken during the sickness absence, during School Closure periods.
4. Chartered Teacher Scheme
The award of salary increments for teachers commencing modules on an accredited Chartered Teacher Programme, currently set out in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Section 1, paragraph 1.25, shall be suspended with immediate effect, with the following exception. Teachers who are already working towards completion of a module or modules, shall receive one salary increment on successful completion of the module or modules. However, until further notice is provided, no additional salary increments shall be awarded for any further modules of study which are completed.
The SNCT will take a decision on the awarding of additional increments for teachers undertaking an accredited Chartered Teacher programme by April 2012.
5. National Teacher Induction Scheme
From 1 August 2011, the amount of class contact time for teachers on the National Teacher Induction Scheme shall increase from 15.75 hours to 18.5 hours per week. The SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Section 3, paragraph 3.5 and Section 9, paragraph 9.10 will be amended accordingly.
6. Supply Teachers’ Pay
6.1 Supply teaching
All periods of cover teaching for periods of 5 days or less will be defined as supply. Supply teaching is where teachers may be offered work on a short term temporary basis, generally with little notice, and usually on a day-to-day basis. In such instances there is no obligation on the council to provide work or on the teacher to accept the offer of work. Each separate period of engagement of less than 5 days will be treated as a separate contract.
The duties required of a supply teacher will be to teach assigned classes together with associated preparation and correction.
From August 2011, for periods of supply of 5 days or less, payment will be on point 1 of the Main Grade Scale and for a maximum of 25 hours (comprising a maximum of 22.5 hours class contact and 2.5 hours set aside for preparation and correction, pro-rated for those who work for less than a full week). In situations where the supply period exceeds the initial 5 days, then the teacher should be issued with a fixed term temporary contract. From the 6th day onwards payment, working hours and duties will be in accordance with the SNCT Handbook.
6.2 Fixed Term Appointments
Where it is known at the outset that the period of engagement is to be more than 5 days then the teacher should be issued with a fixed term contract as described in Appendix 2.8 paragraph 3.1 of the SNCT Handbook. Payment, working hours and duties will be in accordance with the SNCT Handbook.
The relevant provisions in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Sections 1.23 and 1.69, remain. The relevant provisions in the SNCT Handbook, Part 2, Sections 1 and 3 will be amended to reflect these changes.
7. Local Government Settlement
Scottish Government and COSLA propose that the local government settlement is increased by £15.31m above the level set out in the Local Government Finance Order, to be allocated as a redetermination following agreement with COSLA over the distribution methodology. That amount will be added to baseline provision for the purposes of the next Spending Review.
Members wishing to register their vote online can do so using the link below. You require your ballot paper with the unique reference number to vote. You must enter the reference number when you vote.
Please note that if a vote is registered online and a postal vote is also made, BOTH votes will be regarded as spoilt papers.
The result of the consultative ballot will be published on our website as soon as possible after the ballot closes at 12 noon on 28 April 2011.
You can vote online now.
SSTA representatives at the SNCT meeting on Wednesday 23 March did not accept the new proposal, making it clear that in this Association members make policy decisions. A vote on the revised proposal was taken at the Teachers’ Side pre-meeting and 6 of the 19 members did not vote in favour of accepting the proposal. A ballot will be held to enable members to state their views and influence our stance. Further details below…
Dear Colleagues
At the SNCT meeting held today £15.3m was offered by the Scottish Government to offset part of the £60m of cuts to teachers’ conditions of service made by COSLA and support the retention of teachers’ conditions of service. Those changes are detailed below.
SSTA representatives at the meeting, mindful of the overwhelming rejection of the previous final offer made by COSLA & the Government, made it clear that the decision would be made by SSTA members, not by officials. Salaries and Conditions of Service committee meets on Monday and will decide what recommendation, if any, to make to members.
Changes To the Proposal
There are 2 areas where changes have been made to the proposal previously sent to members. These are:
Fixed term appointments where the period of engagement is known to extend beyond 5 days will be paid at the appropriate scale point for 35 hours per week.
Existing proposals pertaining to:
Pay freeze;
Conservation of salary;
annual leave;
the charter teacher scheme;
and the national teacher induction scheme
remain as before.
Teacher Numbers
COSLA have agreed that if teacher numbers fall below 53,131 in the census completed in September 2011 then conditions of service may be restored to an equal value of the shortfall in numbers employed .
The decision made by Salaries and Conditions of Service Committee will be posted on the website by close of business on Monday.
Wednedsay 23 March 2011
Dear Colleagues
The results of the recent consultative ballot are listed at the end of the message. These results will be formally intimated to COSLA and The Scottish Government at the next meeting of the SNCT. This will take place at 2pm on Wednesday 23 March 2011. Any Information from the outcome of the meeting will be posted on the website by Thursday 24 March 2011.
Information will also be emailed to members as soon as possible after the close of the meeting.
| Q1. Do you accept the proposed changes to your conditions of service as detailed in the enclosed document. | ||
| Yes, I accept the proposals | 4.6% | |
| No, I do not accept the proposals | 95.4% | |
| Q2. If the changes are imposed by COSLA I would | ||
| agree to consider industrial action short of strike action. | 31.1% | |
| agree to consider industrial action including strike action. | 61.2% | |
| not consider industrial action | 6.7% |
